BLP (25)
Terms
undefined, object
copy deck
- What was the most significant reform to the law of insolvency and when did it come into force?
- It was contained in the Enterprise Act 2002 and came into force on 15 September 2003.
- Can directors ignore financial difficulties and keep a company trading?
- If the Co is liquidated, directors can be made personally liable to contribute to the company's assets under the IA (the sections dealing with wrongful or fraudulent trading).
- What are the implications in relation to directors duties once a company finds itself in financial trouble?
- S. 172 duty to promote the success of the company switches to protecting the interests of creditors.
- What can happen if a director does not exercise power under s. 172(3) when a company finds itself in financial difficulty?
- Director can be held liable for to pay damages to the Co under s. 212 IA 1986 which deals with misfeasance.
- Aside from paying damages to the company, how else might a director be impacted?
- Disqualification risk under Company Directors Disqualification Act 1986.
- What options are open to directors who intend to turn around the fortunes of a failing company?
-
1. restructuring the company's debt;
2. replace some directors;
3. appoint turn around specialists. - Are informal agreements usually legally enforceable?
- No, on the basis that there is no consideration for forbearance of a debt, therefore an informal agreement is unlikely to be enforceable as a matter of contract.
- What is the advantage of a formal agreement?
- Legally binding
- What are the two types of formal arrangement that can be made?
-
1. Scheme of arrangement (s. 895 - 901 CA 06); or
2. Company Voluntary Arrangement (s. 1-7 IA 1986). - What is a scheme of arrangement?
-
1. Complex formal arrangement;
2. Compromises between creditors and Co;
3. 3/4 in value of the relevant creditors must agree;
4. Must be sanction by the court
5. A sanctioned scheme binds any dissenting or unknown creditors - When are Schemes of Arrangment for often used and why?
- For complex group insolvencies owing to the cost and court's involvement.
- What is a Company Voluntary Arrangement (CVA)?
-
1. Less costly than Scheme of Arrangement;
2. Put in place a timetable for repayment;
3. CVA is implemented and supervised by an insolvency practitioner. - Describe the process of setting up a Company Voluntary Arrangement?
-
1. Directors of company formulate written proposals for repayment of the company's debts;
2. Proposals include nominated IP;
3. Creditors and shareholders vote (in two separate meetings) to approve plan and IP appointment. - Who usually advises directors trying to put a Company Voluntary Arrangement in place?
- The nominated insolvency practitioner.
- What happens in the event of a conflict between votes case at the creditors' meeting and members' meeting in the context of putting a Company Voluntary Arrangement in place?
- The decision of the creditors' meeting prevails.
- Who is bound by the approval of a CVA?
-
1. Not only creditors who were given notice of and entitled to vote; also
2. all creditors who would have been entitled to vote, had they been given notice;
3. creditors under 2 (above) can claim as if they were a party to the CVA. - Can a secured or preferential creditors' rights to their priority position be affected or prejudiced without their consent?
- No.
- In terms of buying time to put a rescue plan in place, what can directors do?
- Small companies can apply to the court for a short moratorium (initially 28 days). Rare in practice.
- What was the intended purpose of Administration?
-
1. provide breathing space
2. during which creditors are unable
3. without court consent
4. to enforce security
5. or take other enforcement action - For the purpose of a administration, when can a charge holder appoint an administrator?
- Only if the charge is a Qualifying Floating Charge, defined in Sch B1, para 14.
- Who can apply to court to appoint an administrator?
-
1. the company (members in GM);
2. the directors (by BR);
3. a creditor;
4. a supervisor of a CVA; and
5. a liquidator - Who can use the out of court procedure to appoint an administrator?
-
1. the company;
2. directors;
3. a Qualifying Floating Charge Holder (the QFCH). - If a QFCH appoints an administrator? When does the appointment commence?
- The date of the notice.
- If the company or its directors appoint an administrator, when does the appointment commence?
-
1. must file notice to appoint at court and serve on QFCH;
2. The QFCH has 5 days in which to appoint its own administrator
3. i.e. QFCH can veto.
4. If no veto, Co or its directors may appoint by filing notice to court in a further 5 day window. - What does the appointment of an administrator create?
- An immediate moratorium on enforcement action.
- Can a QFCH's choice of administrator override the choice of an unsecured creditor?
- Yes. There is an interim moratorium if the unsecured creditor applies which gives the QFCH time to use the out of court procedure to appoints its choice of administrator.
- What must directors do pending the appointment of an administrator?
- Must merely preserve the company's business and assets until appointment.
- On a practical note, what has to happen while a company is in administration?
- All business stationery must state that the Co is in administration.
- During administration (post appointment), what can directors do/not do?
- Cannot exercise any management power without the consent of the administrator.
- To whom does an administrator owe duties?
-
1. officer of the court;
2. under a duty to act in the interests of all the creditors. - When does an administrator's appointment terminate?
-
1. Automatically after 12 months.
2. Can be extended by 6 months if the creditors agree.
3. Court can also sanction and other extensions. - Can an administrator sue the directors for any part they played in causing or exacerbating the creditors' losses?
- No, unlike the liquidator.
- Can an administrator bring administration to an end?
- Yes by filing the appropriate notice to the court.
- Who are fixed charge receivers?
- Appointed by the holder of a fixed charge in the circumstances set out in the security documentation.
- What property can a fixed charge receiver deal with?
- Only the property charged. (S)he is only able to deal with that property.
- What are fixed charge receivers often referred to as?
- LPA receivers
- What is the Relevant Date, i.e. when the EA 2002 came into force?
- 15 September 2003
- Who are administrative receivers?
- Debentures entered into pre the Relevant Date (15 September 2003), were able to appoint ARs. Effectively abolished post Relevant Date.
- How could the holder of a floating charge appoint an Administrative Receiver?
-
1. Without formality; and
2. provided the terms confer on the QFCH permit appointment. - What were the powers of administrative procedures?
-
1. All express powers set out in debenture;
2. Extensive powers set out under Sch 1. - What was the most important power of an Administrative Receiver?
- Take possession of, get in and sell the assets of the company to repay the debenture holder.
- What is liquidation?
- The realisation and distribution of the assets of a to company to its creditors
- What is liquidation also referred to as?
- winding up
- What are the two types of liquidation?
- Voluntary and compulsory
- What two types of voluntary liquidations exist?
-
1. Members' voluntary liquidation
2. Creditors' voluntary liquidation - When will dissolution take place under a compulsory liquidation?
-
1. Three months
2. After notice by the liquidator
3. To the Registrar
4. that the winding up of the Co is complete. - When will dissolution take place under a voluntary liquidation?
-
1. Three months;
2. from the filing by the liquidator
3. of the company's
4. final accounts and return. - What happens after the dissolution of the company?
- The company ceases to exist.
- Who can issue the petition for compulsory liquidation?
-
1. a creditor
2. the company (would usually go into voluntary as cheaper and quicker)
3. the directors (same applies)
4. an administrator
5. an administrative receiver
6. the supervisor of a CVA
7. the SoS for Business, Innovation and Skills (on public police grounds). - What are the usual grounds for compulsory liquidation?
-
1. Co's inability to pay its debts (s. 122(1)(f));
2. Court of the opinion that its 'just and equitable' to wind up the company (s. 122(1)(g)). - How do you know if a company is unable to pay its debts? Auth?
- Consider the definition in s. 123 IA 1986
- When is the members' voluntary liquidation procedure utilised?
- Only when the Co is solvent.
- What resolutions need to be passed for the purpose of entering into a members' voluntary liquidation?
-
1. A SR approving the members' voluntary liquidation; and
2. An OR appointing a liquidator. - Can a members' voluntary liquidation be converted into a creditors' voluntary liquidation?
- Yes, if the company becomes unable to pay its debts within the period specified in the statutory declaration (given under s. 89(1) of the IA.
- What is a creditors insolvent liquidation?
-
1. Commenced by resolution of the members;
2. but under the effective control of the creditors
3. who can choose the liquidator - What resolutions do shareholders need to pass to enter into a creditors voluntary liquidation?
-
1. A SR to approve the CVL; and
2. An OR to provisionally appoint a liquidator. - What happens after the members of a company pass the necessary resolutions to enter into a CVL?
-
1. A creditors' meeting is convened within 14 days;
2. The directors provide a statement of the company's affairs;
3. The creditors vote to appoint their own appointee as liquidator. - Bar realising the company's assets, what else should a liquidator do?
- Maximise the assets available for distribution to the company's creditors.
- How does a liquidator maximise the assets available for distribution to the company's creditors?
-
1. Challenging voidable transactions
2. Disclaiming onerous property (s. 178) - Does a liquidator need to get permission before taking certain actions?
-
Yes. The liquidator needs the consent of the committee of creditors (if appointed) or the court:
1. before commencing legal proceedings; or
2. to carry on running the business. - Should there be sufficient monies to pay preferential creditors, what are employees entitled to?
-
1. Remuneration due in the four months before winding up/petition;
2. £800.00 per employee (max) plus accrued holiday pay and certain contributions owning to a pension scheme. - What is the ring-fenced fund?
- A pot of money effectively shared equally between the floating charge creditors and unsecured creditors.
- How is the ring fenced fund calculated?
-
The following proportions of the company's net property:
1. 50% of first £10,000; and
2. 20% thereafter up to a maximum fund of £600,000. - What do the ring fence provisions apply to?
-
1. Realisations from floating charges created on or after the Relevant Date; and
2. Where the net property of the company is less than £10,000 (cost would outweigh the benefit). - Calculate your insolvency dividend
-
1. Divide the 'total amount available to unsecured creditors' by the amount that remains due.
2. times that figure by 100 = 'insolvency dividend of [figure] pence for every £1 owed'. - Do you need to create a ring-fenced fund of no floating charge holder ranks above the unsecured creditors?
- No.