Personal Property VA FINAL
Terms
undefined, object
copy deck
- What are the 3 types of found property?
-
1) abandoned property
2) lost property
3) mislaid property - With respect to abandoned property, what are the two key inquiries?
-
1) Is the property abandoned?
-Abandoned if owner has given up possession with the intent to give up title and control
2) If it is abandoned, has someone acquired rights to it?
-Did the finder have possession with the intent to assert title and control? - So, what are the two key elements in an abandoned property question?
-
Possession and intent
1) owner has given up possession; finder has acquired possession
2) owner had intent to give up title and control; finder had intent to acquire tite and control - Who are the 2 characters in most lost/mislaid property questions?
-
1) the finder
2) the land owner or occupier
Note: true owner absent because he would always win - What is the definition of lost property?
- No voluntary act was taken in placing the property where it was found.
- Who wins in a lost property question? Finder or land owner/occupier?
-
GR: finder wins
EX: if finder is a trespasser, then owner/occupier wins (trespassers always lose)
EX: master prevails over servant
EX: highly private locus exception - What is the highly private locus exception?
- It defeats the GR that the finder of lost property prevails and says that if the place of finding was a highly private locus (home or office), then the land owner/occupier wins.
- What is the definition of mislaid property?
- The owner has take some affirmative act in placing the property where it is found and left it behind.
- Who wins in the mislaid property situation? Finder or land owner/occupier?
- Owner/occupier wins
- Give an example that distinguishes between lost and mislaid property.
-
1) walking aisle in store, wallet falls out of coat = lost property (finder prevails)
2) put wallet on counter in store and forget to pick it up (owner prevails) - What is the very general rule w/r/t gifts? (when does title pass)
- If a gift is given, title passes.
- What are the two types of gifts?
-
1) inter vivos
2) causa mortis - What 3 elements are necessary for a valid inter vivos gift?
-
1) donative intent (easier to find if d'or and d'ee closely related)
-intent to pass title NOW
-has nothing to do with possession (oil painting example)
2) valid delivery
-giving to someone sufficient
-also sufficient to give a symbolic representation of a gift (savings account passbook)
3) valid acceptance
-implied through silenve
-must have explicit rejection to invalidate acceptance -
When is delivery complete in the following situation?
Donor makes out check or promissory note to donee. - NO delivery until check is CASHED or note PAID
-
When is delivery complete in the following situation?
Donor hands donee check or note made out to donor by a third party. - YES delivery even if d'or hasn't indorsed.
-
When is delivery complete in the following situation?
Donor hands donee stock certificate. - YES delivery even if no indorsement or notification to corporation of transfer
-
When is delivery complete in the following situation?
Donor uses middleman to get the gift to donee. -
Depends on whose agent the middle man is.
1) middleman is d'or's agent --- no delivery until agent delivers to d'ee
2) middleman is d'ee's agent --- delivery when given to agent
3) FOR MINOR D'EEs, construe middleman as d'ee's agent - What type of peril must a donor be contemplating for a valid gift causa mortis?
-
Fair degree of certainty, OR Likelihood of death that is imminent and likely to occur
2 examples for bar purposes:
1) lying on sidewalk after being hit by a bus
2) being in hospital with terminal illness - What are the 3 ways a gift causa mortis is revoked?
-
1) d'or voluntarily revokes before death
2) d'ee predeceases d'or
3) d'or recovers (automatically revoked by operation of law) - Is a gift causa mortis revoked if donor dies but of something other than the peril that caused the gift?
- NO! It is no longer revocation. Death of some sort after the peril is good enough.
- How do you know when a bailment exists?
-
CUSTODY AND INTENT
-When bailor has taken over custody of chattel w/ intent to serve as bailee (must intend to serve as bailee--doesn't count if something is hidden in the car that's unexpected but expected items, intent is presumed) - Are items unknown items inside a safe deposit box bailments?
- Yes even though bank has no idea what's inside th box.
- Is a car in a parking lot/garage considered a bailment?
-
1) if driver keeps keys, NO
2) if lot/garage keeps keys, YES - What liability does a bailee (he who receives the bailment) have for damaged/destroyed/missing bailment?
-
It depends on the standard of care.
1) if for the sole benefit of the bailor (he who turns over the chattel) -- only GROSS NEGLIGENCE
-also called a gratuitous bailment
2) if for sole benefit of the bailee (he who receives the bailment), then liable for even SLIGHT NEGLIGENCE
3) if mutual benefit --- liable for ORDINARY NEGLIGENCE - When is bailee strictly liable?
-
1) SL for unauthorized use
2) GR: SL for misdelivery
EX: if bailee misdelivers car in parking lot when presented with forged claim check, not SL - Are exculpatory clauses effective in limiting liability for bailees?
-
GR: yes, bailee can limit liability for negligence so long as bailor received EFFECTIVE NOTICE of the limitation (e.g., if in fine print--no effective notice; if huge sign--effective notice)
EX: can only limit liability for ordinary negligence, not gross negligence or intentional torts - What is the general definition of a common carrier?
- One who undertakes to for hire to transport persons or goods from place to place.
- What are the 3 requirements to qualify as a common carrier?
-
1) holding out to perform service for all who apply
2) carriage must be for hire
3) service must be for carriage (e.g., in the transport business) - What is the significance of qualifying as a common carrier?
- -Considered an insurer of the goods transported and liable for any damage or loss with 3 exceptions
- What are the 3 exceptions to a common carrier being liable as an insurer for all loss/damage of chattels?
-
1) goods damaged by act of nature
2) goods damaged/destroyed by faulty packaging by shipper
3) goods are perishable and damaged because nature took its course